Holy Innocents
Columnist Tim Montgomerie reflects on the resonance of the Feast of the Holy Innocents for Christians in the Middle East.
"They will be acutely aware of the empty spaces in the pews which should have been filled by brothers, sisters, parents, children and friends whose lives were cut short by a reign of terror that sickened the whole world."
In a series exploring the enduring significance of the Nativity story, columnist Tim Montgomerie reflects on the resonance of the Feast of the Holy Innocents for Christians in the Middle East.
Producer: Dan Tierney.
Last on
More episodes
Previous
Next
You are at the last episode
Script - Holy Innocents
For Christians in much of the Middle East and Africa - where going to church or even reading the Bible on a bus risks death or persecution – there is no great need for the seasonal reminder that, while King Herod may be long gone, the evil he represented is as dark and forbidding as it ever was.
I say “seasonal” but we in the west have relegated the story of Herod to an afterthought in the schmaltzy, inoffensive way that we celebrate Jesus Christ’s birth. But the murderous reaction of Herod to the infant king’s arrival – who he saw as a threat to his own rule and, as part of a sledgehammer plan to kill him, ordered the murder of all of Bethlehem’s newborn boys – has had its echo in every age.
While Christians in Syria will be celebrating their belief that, contrary to what they feared until very recently, their country will not be overtaken by Islamist extremists, there will be no great confidence about the next few years. The same for Christians in Iraq, who will be ringing the bells again of the churches in and around Mosul that were ransacked and conquered by Isis two years ago.
There is unlikely to be much gratitude either for the last two American presidents. Although it would be wrong to attribute to the view to all of Syria’s Christians, many feel Barack Obama was naïve about their country’s rebellion and what a victory for the rebels would have meant for them. Many Christians in Iraq, meanwhile, lay much of the blame for their sufferings at the forces unleashed by George W Bush’s decision to topple Saddam Hussein.
I’m not sure that the persecuted, frightened Christians of our age – from Nigeria to Egypt - have given much thought to what the next president of the United States might mean for them but, as I discovered on my mission to understand why so many American evangelicals had voted for Donald J Trump, some hope that he might be a significant champion of them.
ĚýĚý
During the last year, as I reported for The Times on the most extraordinary of races for the White House, I spent a lot of time in the Bible Belt. I constantly underestimated the willingness of Americans to vote for Mr Trump and the willingness of so many evangelicals and Catholics to vote for him was a puzzle to me.
One conversation after a Sunday morning service stuck in my mind – and not just because I still treasure the memory of some southern fried chicken that, because it was so delicious, might even have tempted the devil to turn up for morning worship.
Not surprisingly, I heard the usual concerns about Hillary Clinton’s ethics and the so-called religious right’s long-held hope that Mr Trump would tilt the membership of the Supreme Court against abortion was also a factor.
Interestingly, however, and it featured prominently in other conversations I’ve since had, this issue of persecution of Christians in the Middle East and beyond was at the front of Christian minds. And it meant that Trump’s rough, uninhibited, pugilistic style was not the problem I had expected it to be – it was, instead, seen as an asset.
One man looked at me directly, wiping a few chicken breadcrumbs from his beard as he spoke:
“I’m under no illusions about Mr Trump” he said. “His marriages and sexual immorality. His personal meanness. I wouldn’t go within a mile of any church where someone like him was the preacher. But we’re not electing a preacher. We’re electing a president. More than that, a commander-in-chief. And he is our Putin – and the dark forces in this world will only be crushed by men like Putin.”
And by dark forces he meant ISIS, Al-Qaida and the other forms of extremist Islam that Russia’s President has vowed to defeat – and, closer to home but much less deadly, the liberal judges who Christians blamed for a steady erosion of their religious freedoms.
Mr Trump, who at this time of year is loud in wishing people a Merry Christmas rather than the “happy holidays” employed by the more politically correct, may however have a limited grasp of Christianity’s key teachings. Asked to name his favourite Bible verse, for example, the president-elect nominated Exodus 21:24 – that Old Testament injunction to not show pity but to exact an “eye for an eye, a tooth for a tooth, a hand for a hand.” Jesus’ encouragement to turn the other cheek hasn’t informed Mr Trump’s best-selling guides to succeeding in commerce. "When you are in business you need to get even with people who screw you,” he wrote. “You need to screw them back 15 times harder ... go for the jugular, attack them in spades!"
And this going for the jugular was just what a good number of Christians are hoping to see from a Trump White House. They know he isn’t a regular Christian but some have come to think regular Christians might not be the prescription that our age’s ills require. George W Bush was, after all, a born-again evangelical who, through faith, had turned his life around at the age of forty and conquered personal demons, notably alcohol. Once asked to name the political philosopher who had influenced him most, Mr Bush answered “Jesus Christ”. But the presidency of this impeccably credentialed Christian now is widely now seen as a disaster for many Christians in the region where the story of Jesus began.
The decline of Christianity in the Middle East predated Mr Bush’s wars, of course. Compared to the beginning of the 20th century when one-sixth of the region’s population was Christian, it’s now barely one-twentieth. But the collapse in Iraq has been frighteningly rapid. A Christian population of 1.5 million under Saddam Hussein had, via migration and war, collapsed to about 300,000 by 2014 and then, as Isis advanced and Christians fled in terror, it sank to under 200,000. The grave warnings of bloodshed and “a new gulf between Christianity and Islam”, made by the Vatican to President Bush - all before he ordered the start of hostilities - have sadly come to pass.
But this Christmas, there is some good news for Christians. ISIS is being driven out of the lands it conquered two years ago. There have been inspirational reports of church bells ringing again for the first time in two years. Although some of the liberated churches have been damaged by fire and some walls have been defaced by graffifi – with Isis fighters scrawling “our God is higher than the cross' and 'The Islamic State will remain' – many thousands of Christians are expected to return from their forced exile – if they can also repossess homes which were often taken over by neighbours who calculated ISIS’ rule would last longer than, thankfully, it did.
It won’t just be the birth of Jesus that these churches will celebrate this year. Many will mark how Herod reacted to the birth through what is called the Feast of the Holy Innocents. Once a central part of the church’s calendar it’s now pretty marginal to the western church’s contemporary Christmas.
The Feast, usually celebrated on the 28th December, remembers the dark side of this season. Herod had expected the Magi to be his informers and lead him to the location of the rival king of the Jews but, living up to their names, the wise men refused to be his accomplices. Undeterred, Herod’s soldiers murdered every boy of two years or under as part of his desperate attempt to kill the one child. “A voice was heard in Ramah,” declares the 18th verse of the second chapter of St Matthew, “weeping and great mourning, Rachel weeping for her children, and refusing consolation, because they are no more.”
The Feast has, through the ages, become a time not just to remember these first martyrs but all martyrs since. One can only imagine how poignant the Feast must be for Iraq’s Christians. They will be acutely aware of the empty spaces in the pews which should have been filled by brothers, sisters, parents, children and friends whose lives were cut short by a reign of terror that sickened the whole world – and not least peace-loving Muslims who are appalled by what ISIS does in their name.
But, let’s now return to those Christians I met in South Carolina and their hope for Trump to become some sort of Vladimir Putin. Mr Putin may have played no part in Iraq’s recent story but he has been central to events in Syria. The regime of Bashar al-Assad might have survived without the Kremlin’s enormous support but Russian munitions, aircraft and counter-insurgency techniques developed by Putin in his war against Chechnya twenty years ago have given Assad the supremacy that has now caused such slaughter in the downfall of Eastern Aleppo. Leading the thanks for Mr Putin are many but by no means all of Syria’s Christians. They faced a moral dilemma in supporting President Assad, but feared, just as the Arab Spring often became something of a “winter for Christians”, their freedom of worship would be lost if the extreme elements opposed to Assad had prevailed.
Echoing that congregation in South Carolina, the Christian blogger and author Rod Dreher issued “1.5 cheers for Putin” in a much remarked upon posting. “What an embarrassment that post-Soviet Russia, for all its grievous flaws, is, in important ways more conscious of its Christian history and character than the United States.” Dreher continued: Russia’s President “is anti-liberal in ways that are morally objectionable, but also in ways that are morally praiseworthy. The Christians of the Middle East, he wrote, have a greater friend in Vladimir Putin than they do in Barack Obama — or that they did in George W. Bush, for that matter.”
This is music to Mr Putin’s ears who since becoming his country’s president has positioned himself as the closest ally of the Russian Orthodox Church. Although it is not officially part of the state it has started to resume its traditional role of close service of the governing regime. Before the 2012 presidential election the head of the church even described the government’s economic record as a miracle. Mr Putin, who includes the church in great events of state, sometimes uses Orthodoxy to justify his militarism.
As many Christians in America pay grudging respects to Mr Putin and even hope that President Trump will somehow model himself on the Kremlin’s strongman, a basic awareness of his more self-serving interpretation of Christianity should be understood. Many Christians may have been protected by his military intervention but was that Mr Putin’s real motivation or were his actions geopolitical - in defense of his most important Middle Eastern client?
And here is the big question going back to the Feast of the Holy Innocents and a remembrance of martyrdom - Is Putin Herod or the Magi? The defender of Christians in Syria from the great evil of terrorist extremists or is he the co-author of a bombing campaign that has turned Aleppo into a modern day Stalingrad? For many years to come the orphans, widows and other “massacred innocents” of the Syrian civil war will remember what was done to them and some will remember that it was done by politicians claiming to be guardians of Christendom.
What I hold onto is the hope in the biblical story itself.
Herod spilt a great deal of innocent blood in his attempt to kill Jesus but his mission was not accomplished. Just as Christians know that the crucifixion of Jesus failed too. That’s why, despite the bleak picture and the controversial choices of world leaders, this season’s story of the arrival of the prince of peace is a hopeful one. It’s hopeful for all of us but, particularly at this moment in time, especially hopeful for the Christians of the Middle East and of the persecuted church throughout the world.
Broadcast
- Fri 23 Dec 2016 22:45ĂŰŃż´«Ă˝ Radio 3
Featured in...
Christmas on Radio 3—Christmas around Europe
Enjoy the very best in music, words, and ideas this festive season.
Death in Trieste
Watch: My Deaf World
The Book that Changed Me
Five figures from the arts and science introduce books that changed their lives and work.
Podcast
-
The Essay
Essays from leading writers on arts, history, philosophy, science, religion and beyond.